Shredded Mexican Chicken Casserole (2024)

This Mexican Chicken Casserole is a super simple weeknight meal that packs in the flavor and leaves you craving more! Made with tender shredded chicken, salsa, black beans, corn, and a special blend of spices, it takes all the best flavors and combines them into a quick and easy one dish dinner!

From Shredded Chicken to Mexican Casserole!

This Mexican Chicken Casserole is a busy night super-meal since it takes regular shredded chicken you have on hand, and transforms it in in minutes into a flavor packed meal that both the kids and adults will love!

You can use shredded chicken from the freezer, shredded chicken you make fresh, or you can grab a rotisserie chicken at the store and pull the meat off to make this dinner fast! 3 options to make this meal easy, no matter what you have on hand!

We all love this recipe, but my kids especially enjoy it! They ask for it often because they think it tastes like nachos, which is one of their favorite dinners!

It really does pack in all of our favorite Mexican flavors, into a simple and super delicious dinner! Make sure to bookmark some of our other Mexican favorites like these Easy Steak Fajitas, the viral Chicken Burrito Casserole, or this Cheesy Taco Skillet.

Recipe Step by Step

1. Measure out the shredded chicken- You can use a little more or less depending on the size of your dish.
2. Combine the chicken with salsa, black beans, corn, and seasonings. Stir to coat it all.
3. Spread the chicken back in the casserole dish and cover with cheese.
4. Bake the casserole until heated throughout and the cheese is melted. Garnish with your choice of sour cream, green onions and cilantro.

My Tips for Making Shredded Mexican Chicken Casserole

Mexican Chicken Casserole is a super simple dish, but there are a few tips I can share to make sure it turns out the best possible.

I will also try to answer some frequently asked questions here, so if something comes up while cooking you have an answer. If I miss your question, please leave me a note in the comments at the end of this post.

Shredded Chicken

The main ingredient in this dish is shredded chicken. You can really use any type of shredded chicken you like to make this.

My best advice is that the quality of the chicken makes a big impact on the flavor, so use a type that you really enjoy.

Here are a few options for shredded chicken.

• Oven– If you need an easy recipe to make shredded chicken I LOVE thisbaked chicken breast.
• Stove top– Chicken can be boiled until done, then cooled and shredded.
• Crock pot– Slow cook with mild seasonings, then shed and store.
• Rotisserie– Store bought or homemade rotisserie chicken can be pulled and used. This is one of the most flavorful options for this dish.
• Canned– If you are in a pinch or have canned chicken that needs to be used up, it will work in this recipe. This is my least favorite option for this dish.

I like to use one of the methods above to bulk prepare shredded chicken and store in the freezer. This allows me to make this meal in minutes since a having the meat already prepared takes a huge chunk of time off of the time this meal takes!

The Salsa

Use a good quality, flavorful salsa that is not watery. You will want the tomatoes to coat the chicken as you mix the dish together.

I generally prefer fresh salsa, but in this dish, jarred works best since the tomatoes tend to be less watery and more saucey.

The Corn and Black Beans

The recipe calls for canned corn and black beans. I use these specifically for convenience in this recipe. They are a pantry staple and allow you to make this meal in a flash using things you keep on hand.

If you prefer, you can absolutely use alternates for these. Frozen corn, or prepared dried black beans would both work well.

Substitutions

This Mexican Chicken Casserole is pretty forgiving! You can add or remove an ingredient based on your preferences or what you have on hand and still likely get a great result. Here are some common substitutions.

• Black Beans– Pinto beans can be substituted.
• Corn– Other varieties like Mexican corn can be used. You can also add additional veggies like chopped onion or chopped bell pepper if desired.
• Salsa– Green salsa (salsa verde) can be used in place of red salsa. You could also use enchilada sauce in a pinch!
• Colby Jack cheese– Almost any basic cheese will work on this casserole. Cheddar, Mexican blend, and monterey jack are all great substitutes.
• Sour Cream– Low fat, or fat free sour cream can be used.

Dietary Restrictions

I hope you are able to make the recipe as written, but if you do have a special dietary need, this Mexican Chicken Casserole is easily able to adapt to accommodate many needs!

• Gluten Free– This recipe is naturally gluten free. Make sure that you check labels on specific products used to make sure they comply.
• Dairy Free– To make this casserole dairy free, omit the cheese, or use dairy free cheese and no sour cream.
• Grain or legume free– To make this casserole grain or legume free, you can omit the corn and black beans and substitute other veggies such as chopped pepper, diced zucchini, chopped cauliflower etc.

Mexican Chicken Casserole Freezing Instructions

This meal freezes well both before or after cooking. Follow the directions below for freezer instructions:

To freeze before cooking:

1. Prepare the Mexican Chicken Casserole either through step 1 and store in a plastic zip top bag, or through step 2 and store in a casserole dish.
2. Freeze
3. When ready to cook, thaw in the refrigerator.
4. Add cheese is prepared through step 1, or if prepare through step 2, uncover.
5. Cook as directed.

Note: The advantage of leaving the cheese off is just that you can save space in the freezer and keep your casserole dishes unoccupied. If you don’t want to have to remember the cheese, or you are making it for friends or family, then you can prepare with the cheese in a ready to bake casserole dish.

To freeze after cooking:

1. Follow recipe and cook as directed.
2. Allow casserole to cool.
3. Divide the casserole into meal sized portions and freeze individually in an airtight container or zip top bag.
4. When ready to eat, thaw in the refrigerator, then reheat as desired.

Mexican Chicken Casserole Leftovers

Absolutely one of the best parts about this recipe is the leftovers! Since it makes so loved by the family, we don’t always have them, but we celebrate when we do because it makes a quick and delicious meal later in the week (or month if you freeze!)

To Save

To save leftovers, package the Mexican Chicken Casserole in meal sized portions and place

• in the refrigerator for 3-4 days
• in the freezer for up to a month

Once you have it stored, you can pull it out to make any of these great meals below, or others that you want to try!

LEFTOVER MEXICAN CHICKEN RECIPES

Here are a few simple ideas on how to reinvent this meal another night as a new and exciting dinner.

• Mexican Chicken Quesadillas– Place Mexican Chicken Casserole inside a tortilla and add extra cheese if desired. Place on a hot skillet with butter and grill each side until golden brown.
• Mexican Chicken Stuffed Shells– Stuff prepared large pasta shells with leftover Mexican Chicken Casserole. Place the shells in a baking dish and cover with red enchilada sauce. Sprinkle with cheese and bake 20-30 minutes or until heated through. Serve with a drizzle of sour cream and chopped cilantro.
• Easy Mexican Chicken and Spinach Enchiladas– Combine leftover Mexican Chicken Casserole and frozen spinach that has been thawed and drained and mix well. Roll the mixture into corn or flour tortillas and place seam side down in a casserole dish. Cover with Enchilada sauce and cheese and bake at 350˚F for 25-35 minutes or until heated through.
• Nacho Stuffed Peppers– Cut mini sweet peppers in half. Place a spoonful of leftover Mexican Chicken Casserole in each pepper “chip” then top each with cheese. Bake at 425 for 12-18 min or until cheese is melted and pepper starts to soften. Top or dip pepper nachos with sour cream, guacamole, and/or salsa.
• Mexican Chicken Salad– Fill a bowl with chopped romaine. Top with leftover Mexican Chicken Casserole, then add fresh tomato, chopped cilantro, and avocado. Drizzle with ranch dressing and garnish with crushed tortilla chips.

There are so many wholesome and flavorful meal options for this Mexican Chicken Casserole. I really hope your family enjoys it as much as mine!

More EASY Dinner Casseroles

If you loved this recipe, we hope that you will add more of our family favorites to your meal plan. Check out our recipe index for all of our recipes, or see a few of my personal favorites below!

• Beef Enchiladas – The way I learned to make them in Texas!
• Baked Chicken Fajitas
• Shredded BBQ Chicken Casserole
• Tuscan Garlic Chicken
• Taco Chicken Casserole

Leave a Reply

1. Rebekah

   February 27, 2024

   
   Made this for the first time yesterday and we really enjoyed it! Thanks for the great recipe!

   Reply

2. Bethany Little

   February 4, 2024

   
   I’ve made this SEVERAL times and it’s always well received even by picky eaters. There’s one that prefers to eat it on a tortilla like a soft taco and/or burrito and I like to use tortilla chips and eat it like a dip. It’s not necessary to have tortilla chips or shells because this dish is really good by itself!!!
   👍👍

   Reply

3. Erin

   July 30, 2023

   
   So flavorful! Easy to make.

   Reply

4. Mrs. Debi

   June 9, 2023

   
   Very easy to prepare. I used leftover fajita chicken and leftover taco chicken in my recipe, and a whole can of black beans. I added Mexican seasoning and served it over rice. Will definitely make this again.

   Reply

5. Rachel

   May 22, 2023

   
   This recipe was awesome! I thought tsp of salt was a little much so I used about 3/4 tsp. Other reviewers said it wasn’t spicy enough so I used medium salsa and a large, diced jalapeño. I added 2 cups of Mexican blend cheese instead of 1 1/2 cups, and used a while can of beans as others suggested. My family devoured it so I’ll be keeping this recipe!

   Reply

   1. Alesa

      October 22, 2023

      
      Please remove 1 teaspoon of salt from this recipe. It ruined the whole casserole. I was so excited, and it came out beautifully, but one bite said it all. No need for salt, other than a dash. Rotisserie chicken is salted, so is salsa.

      Reply

6. Jill

   March 26, 2023

   
   I used chicken from a previous recipe that used adobo sauce. Soooo good. Definitely a home run!!

   Reply