Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (2024)

Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (1)

I'm often asked how to adapt a typical yeast-bread recipe to a sourdough recipe. I could make a guess, - decrease the water, substitute the yeast for sourdough starter, and extend the rising time, but I had not actually tried it.

But a few weeks ago, I ran out of yeast and didn't want to make a special trip to the store when I was hit with an urge to make sticky buns. I figured this was the perfect opportunity to try adapting my mom's sticky bun recipe to sourdough.

I can now say with assurance that it works to adapt a yeast bread recipe to sourdough. Works very well.


Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (2)

When I mixed up the dough, I omitted the yeast, added some active sourdough starter, and cut back the water. I placed the dough in the bowl and began to wait. And wait. It took over four hours for the dough to nearly double in size. Sourdough is never mistaken for the fastest baking method.

Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (3)

After rising, I divided the dough in half, rolled it out, and sprinkled the dough with brown sugar and cinnamon.


Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (4)

I rolled the dough tightly and sliced the dough into fifteen slices and placed it into a 9x13 pan with prepared slurry.

Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (5)

I could have cut them into fewer slices for larger buns, but I knew these will increase in size and be perfect for our family. I did the same with the second half of dough, resulting in two pans of buns.


Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (6)

Again, these took a while to raise (2-3 hours) but eventually they filled the pan and were ready to bake.


Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (7)

After baking, I turned them out onto a pan and let the syrup drip down into the buns.


Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (8)

But the real question - what about the flavor? Do sourdough sticky buns taste sour?

If you have eaten a San Francisco-type sourdough, you know that sourdough can taste truly sour. But not all breads made with a sourdough starter has that distinctive flavor. I actually wish we would use "wild yeast" or some other term instead of "sourdough." Bread that is made with a large quantity of starter and risen in warm temperature won't have as strong a flavor, because it will rise quickly and not allow the "sour" flavors to develop. Bread that is made with less starter and risen cold and slow, will have a more developed flavor.

Your pleasure in more or less flavor will depend upon your goals or your tastes. Our family enjoys sourdough. While my children like if I occasionally make a typical yeast bread, Ed says that the typical yeast bread has no flavor.

(Warning: get your husband hooked on quality bread, and you'll spoil him for any other bread - for life. Last week, when he was traveling for work, I heard a litany of complaints about the horrid sandwich bun he was forced to eat. But doesn't every wife like to know that her husband likes her cooking best?)

But I wasn't sure if the combination of sour and sweet in these sticky buns would be complementary.

There IS an undercurrent of a sweet/sour tang in these buns. And we loved it. It reminded me of a citrus tang, like adding a lemon glaze to a sweet cake.

But of course just one attempt wasn't enough. I had to make these buns again to makes sure that the first try wasn't just a lucky success. And this time they were even better. I omitted the slurry or goo, instead making plain cinnamon buns. Then I added a peanut butter fudge frosting. I'm sorry. We were eating the last of the batch when I realized I had not taken a photo.

Want to try it? Here is the recipe for the sourdough sticky buns adapted from my mom's sticky bun recipe.

SourdoughSticky Buns

1cup warm potato water

1cup mashed potatoes

2cups active sourdough starter

2/3cup butter or oil

1/3cup honey (or 2/3 cup sugar)

2eggs

2tsp salt

3cups white flour

3cups whole wheat flour (more if needed)

Mixall ingredients together. Add more flour if needed to make a soft dough. Knead for five minutes. Place in greased bowl and raise untildoubled (at least 3-4 hours). Divide dough in half and roll half into 12 x18 inch rectangle. Sprinkle with cinnamon andbrown sugar. Roll up jelly-roll style from long side. Slice in 15pieces. Place in 9x13 pan. Repeat with the second half of dough.Raise for 2 (or more) hours until doubled. Bake at 375 for 15-20 minutes.

Variation:Place slurry (or goo) in pan before placing rolls if you want sticky buns. My mom's recipe is 2 cups brown sugar, 1 cup water, 4 T molasses, 4 T butter. Stir together in pan and bring to boil. Simmer for one minute. Pour in baking pan before placing rolls. Remember to flip out of baking pan immediatelyafter baking.

Second Variation: After shaping buns, wrap pan tightly in plastic wrap and place in fridge. They will rise slowly. One or two days later, remove from fridge. Allow to warm up for 30 minutes then bake them for fresh buns.

Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (9)

I'd love to hear your attempts in adapting recipes for sourdough.


Sourdough Sticky Buns {Or How to Adapt a Recipe to Sourdough} (2024)

FAQs

How do you fix sticky sourdough dough? ›

If your dough is too sticky and it's impossible to work with you can add some extra flour, just a little at a time. Make sure you weigh the extra flour you add and then you'll be able to adjust the recipe correctly the next time you bake.

Is sourdough bread supposed to be sticky? ›

Well, sourdough is a stickier, wetter dough than regular yeasted bread. This is mainly because sourdough is higher hydration, meaning it contains more water. While sourdough is a wetter, stickier dough than what you may be used to, it should still be able to be stretched, folded and shaped without too many issues.

How do you fix gummy sourdough bread? ›

Try less water with your flour. Uneven heat in your oven can be the culprit – if you loaf is nicely golden on the outside but gummy or moist in the inside, it's baking too quickly on the outside. Trying reducing the temperature you're baking at and bake for a bit longer.

How do you adjust sourdough flavor? ›

  1. For milder sourdough: Use less whole wheat and less rye, or consider sifting the bran out of whole wheat flour to create high-extraction flour. ...
  2. For more tang: Incorporate some rye flour and/or whole wheat flour early in the bread-making process, such as when feeding the mother culture and the preferment.

Why is my sourdough gluey? ›

When the bulk fermentation goes too long — often when the dough more than doubles or triples in volume — the dough can over ferment. You know the dough has over fermented if, when you turn it out to shape it, it is very slack — if it's like a wet puddle — and very sticky and lacking any strength and elasticity.

Why is my sourdough so gummy? ›

tips for avoiding a gummy sourdough loaf - 1) try making a loaf with lower hydration 2) make sure to develop the gluten sufficiently, whether through autolysing, laminating, kneading, or folding 3) make sure to proof long enough 4) make sure to bake long enough and let the loaf cool before cutring #sourdoughtok # ...

Why is my sourdough bread gummy and dense? ›

One of the most common mistakes is having a dough temperature that's too low for the starter to feed on all the flour in the dough, resulting in a crumb that's dense, with fewer openings. "Starter is happiest and most active at around 75 degrees. If it's a lot colder, the process will be much slower.

Why is my bread gluey? ›

While a nice hot oven can produce a beautiful loaf with a crisp, golden crust, too hot of an oven will cause the crust to finish cooking long before the center of the bread. This will result in undercooked dough with a sticky, chewy texture rather than a fully risen crumb.

Will Overproofed dough be gummy? ›

The baked sourdough loaf is squat.

Properly proofed sourdough bread undergoes the oven spring, which is the final expression of the carbon dioxide gasses in the oven. An overproofed dough lacks the necessary carbon dioxide gas for the added boost. The result is a flat, squat loaf of bread with a tight, gummy crumb.

Why did my sourdough turn out chewy? ›

If you are rubbing your dough with flour before baking to accentuate your scored designs, this too can dehydrate your crust, causing it to be tougher and more chewy. Try just spraying with water before baking or minimising the amount of flour you're using on the surface of your bread.

Is gummy bread overproofed? ›

The crumb structure of an under proofed loaf will be tight and gummy. Because it was not given enough time to develop and trap CO2 gasses, the crumb structure will be very dense, with uneven air bubbles.

What makes sourdough taste better? ›

The key taste compounds include salt, which is directly added to the dough, as well as acetic and lactic acid, produced during fermentation. After these experiments, they applied a technique called “unified flavor quantitation,” which was previously developed by Hofmann's team, to the sourdough bread.

Why does my sourdough not taste like sourdough? ›

Using flours with more ash, or mineral, content, will yield more sour taste. If you can't get enough ash, adding a bit of whole wheat flour to your recipe, which is what is done with the 20% Bran Flour, will boost the sour of a bread. Conversely, using a lower ash flour will tend to produce a milder bread.

What makes sourdough bread taste better? ›

The key tastants in sourdough include salt, acetic acid and lactic acid. Salt is added to the loaves by the baker, but acetic and lactic acids are the byproducts of fermentation.

Can you fix Overproofed dough? ›

Shape the dough into the desired form, such as rolls or loaves. Give it a second rise: If the dough is still workable after deflating, allow it to rise again for a shorter time than the initial proofing. Keep a close eye on the dough during this second rise, as it may grow faster due to the previous fermentation.

How do you fix underproofed sourdough? ›

To fix underproofed bread, next time, give the dough more time to ferment before baking. This could mean additional time in bulk fermentation, proof, or a combination.

What is Overproofed sourdough? ›

Overproofed is when the dough has rested too long and the yeast has continued making carbon dioxide while the strength of the dough (gluten bonds) have begun to wear out. The dough will look very puffy, but when you touch it or move it you may notice it deflate or sag.

Can you stretch and fold sourdough too much? ›

Too little folding can result in weak dough. But too much folding can produce excessive tension and compressive forces. An over-folded dough might have a tighter crumb as the layers of alveoli push against each other and coalesce. In the worst case, excessive folding might cause a dough to tear under too much tension.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Frankie Dare

Last Updated:

Views: 6258

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Frankie Dare

Birthday: 2000-01-27

Address: Suite 313 45115 Caridad Freeway, Port Barabaraville, MS 66713

Phone: +3769542039359

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Baton twirling, Stand-up comedy, Leather crafting, Rugby, tabletop games, Jigsaw puzzles, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Frankie Dare, I am a funny, beautiful, proud, fair, pleasant, cheerful, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.